Dealer vs Locksmith: Who’s Better for Car Key Replacement in Port Elizabeth?

Lion Jooste
Nov 7, 2025
2 min read

Keys hang on hooks against a blue wall. A few black plastic-topped keys stand out among many metal keys. The focus is sharp on the foreground.

Losing a Car Key Can Be Stressful

If you’ve ever misplaced or damaged your car key, you know how frustrating it can be. Many car owners in Port Elizabeth immediately think of visiting a dealership — but did you know an automotive locksmith can often replace your key faster, cheaper, and more conveniently?

Let’s compare both options so you can make the right choice when you need a new car key.

Dealership Key Replacement🔑

Pros:

Guaranteed manufacturer-approved parts.
Access to full key codes for newer models.
Ideal for vehicles still under warranty.

Cons:

Usually requires towing your car to the dealership.
Higher prices due to brand markup.
Longer waiting times (often several days).
No after-hours or weekend service.

💬 Example: If you drive a newer VW, the dealer might take 3–5 business days to order and code your new key — and you’ll pay dealership labor rates.

Locksmith Key Replacement🧰

Pros:

Mobile service — we come to you anywhere in Port Elizabeth.
Same-day key cutting and programming for most makes & models.
Up to 50% cheaper than dealerships.
Works on weekends and after hours.

Cons:

Some very new models may need dealer coding access.
Always confirm your locksmith is licensed and qualified.

💬 Example: GetKeys Auto Locksmith can cut, code, and program a replacement car key at your home or office — usually within an hour.

Comparing the Costs💸

Dealership replacement costs in South Africa can range from R4 500 – R7 000 or more, depending on the car. A professional auto locksmith like GetKeys often provides the same service for 30 –40% less, with no towing fees.